Chicago Deep Dish Pizza... Pappa Nicky's Signature Style

Enjoy the deep flaky crust with loads of fresh cheese, 6 of them (mozzarella, pecorino romano, parmesan, asiago, and a touch of wisconsin cheddar). So thick that you will probably need to use a fork! Be sure to try our NEW CITY LOVE CHICAGO VERSION to Share your Love of Pizza!

$26.00

Boston Style Veggie Pizza

This pizza starts with your choice of crust (traditional NY, Chicago or Philly Sicilian) topped with our special sauce and a blend of feta and mozzarella cheeses, then add: roasted sweet red peppers, kalamata olives, onions, spinach & tomato chunks. It is a combination that we think you will just love. Give it a try soon! NEW... NOW AVAILABLE IN Dairy-Free (See Dairy-Free tab for details).Be sure to try our NEW CITY LOVE BOSTON VERSION to Share your Love of Pizza!

$14.00

Pizza Bianca (White Pizza)

White Pizza is the most popular style in Pennsylvania according to slicelife Magazine. Try it, I think that you will like it as well. We start with our homemade, hand-stretched New York crust, then add a special Garlic sauce, lots of shredded Mozzarella Cheese, Ricotta Cheese, then fresh Whole Milk Mozzarella slices. We then top it off with a special blend of herbs & spices. The result? Cheesy, Garlicky heaven! Be sure to try our NEW CITY LOVE BIANCA VERSION to Share your Love of Pizza!

$13.50

Detroit Pan Pizza

If you have never had this pizza, you really should try it! We start with a soft crust, bake on some Wisconsin Cheddar Cheese around the edges (pizza is cut in half to provide eight(8) sides of baked-on cheesy goodness), then top it with a blend of shredded Mozzarella and more Wisconsin cheddar (Wisconsin cheddar is a rather mild variety of cheddar not bitey like New York or Vermont versions). Finally, we add your favorite toppings, then add Pappa Nicky's awesome sauce along with a garnish of six-cheeses, and our special blend of herbs & spices. It's CHEESE Heaven! Be sure to try our NEW CITY LOVE DETROIT VERSION to Share your Love of Pizza!

$26.00

Philly Sicilian Pizza

The pride of south philly is true to it's sicilian heritage with an airy crust, nicky's special homemade sauce and a little "philly" flair to set it apart from any other sicilian pizza that you may have had. Try it, we think that you will agree! Be sure to try our NEW CITY LOVE PHILLY VERSION to Share your Love of Pizza!

$24.00

New York Classic Pizza

This is Pappas Nicky's version of the New York Classic Original with a soft, foldable crust. Nicky's adds our famous awesome sauce, loads of mozzarella cheese along with your favorite toppings... Superb! Be sure to try our NEW CITY LOVE NY VERSION to Share your Love of Pizza!

$12.50

The South Philly Cheesesteak Pizza

The cheesesteak deluxe is a truly great pizza keeping with the south philly cheesesteak tradition. We start with our philly sicilian crust then add: genuine thinly-sliced real sirloin steak, sautéed fried onions, and green bell peppers (additional toppings available to make it your own are extra). We then top it off with a blend of provolone and mozzarella cheeses to make it truly a deluxe pizza! It’s an explosion of south philly deliciousness in every bite that we think will rival any cheesesteak shop! Just try it, and see for yourself! Be sure to try our NEW CITY LOVE S. PHILLY VERSION to Share your Love of Pizza!

$30.00

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

If you want a pizza that "kicks it up a notch" with a uniquely bold flavor, try our new Buffalo Chicken Pizza. We start off with chunks of white meat Rotisserie chicken on our New York style crust, add Franks Red Hot® Original sauce, some crumbled gorgonzola blue cheese, and a whole lot of Nicky's love to make this a truly special pizza that we are sure you will enjoy. Be sure to try our NEW CITY LOVE BUFFALO VERSION to Share your Love of Pizza!

$14.00

Meat-Lovers Supreme Pizza

Mama Marie suggested that we needed something for Meat Lovers. What we came up with is, in fact, a Meat Lovers Dream! We start off by giving you a choice of crusts, Chicago Deep Dish Crust or Philly Sicilian Crust. Sorry, there is so much on this pizza that a New York Crust won't hold it. We then add Nicky's Awesome Sauce, lots of freshly shredded Mozzarella Cheese, Pepperoni, Sweet Italian Sausage, Bacon, Ground Beef, Onions, and Green Bell Peppers. As the finishing touch we add our 5-cheese Italian blend, then our special herbs & spices. Of course, if there isn't enough on it already, you can certainly add more or customize it to your liking. It's also a great value ($7 savings vs. a-la-carte toppings). Give it a try sometime soon but be ready for a feast of Pizza Goodness! NEW! Now available in Dairy-Free (see dairy-free tab for more details) for those who are lactose intolerant.

$34.00

Texas BBQ Pizza-NEW!

If you're a Hankerin' for Somethin' a little Different, maybe with a little Texas BBQ Flair, this Pizza is for YOU! No red sauce on this one. Instead we replace it with Sweet Baby Rays® Original "Award Winning" BBQ Sauce. Then we add your choice of either Savory Rotisserie Chicken or Tangy Pulled Pork, Red Onion, Bacon, then a blend of Mozzarella & Wisconsin Cheddar Cheeses. As a finishing touch we add a Swirl of even more SBR Sauce! If you really want to "kick it up a notch", add some Jalapeño Peppers! Chicken or Pork, either way we think that you will really enjoy it. Be sure to try our NEW CITY LOVE TEXAS VERSION of either pork or chicken to Share your Love of Pizza!

$28.00

Hawaiian Luau Pizza—NEW!

Enjoy the Savory Hawaiian Flavor of Smoked Premium Ham with the Sweetness of Dole® Pineapple with Pappa Nicky's Exclusive Homemade AwesomeSauce, Red Onions, and Bacon! For an added Kick, we put a swirl of Sweet Baby Rays® Original BBQ Sauce. ~Try it Today~... We think that you will LOVE IT! Be sure to try our NEW CITY LOVE HAWAIIAN VERSION to Share your Love of Pizza!

$14.00

Tomato Pie (17" x 12") — NEW!

Introducing Pappa Nicky's NEW Tomato Pie, a Philly Original! We are using a new sauce recipe exclusively for this Pizza. We start with whole plum San Marzano tomatoes from the volcano region of Italy. They are then oven-baked to bring out the natural sweetness, then added to this new sauce. We are also introducing a new crust for this Pizza that is soft, chewy, and lightly crispy on the bottom. Finally, we finish this special red-top pie with freshly grated Pecorino Romano & Parmesan cheeses. We think you will LOVE this new Pizza. TRY IT TODAY!

$24.00

Margherita Pizza — NEW!

This is Pappa Nicky's version of the original Neapolitan Pizza with a scratch-made thin crust. We then add our famous Chunky Homemade Sauce made from imported Italian Whole Plum Tomatoes. To finish it off, we add loads of FRESH Mozzarella cheese, basil leaves, and fresh garlic. You can also make it your own by adding any of our vast selection of toppings.

$14.00

Stuffed Chicago Deep Dish Pizza — NEW!

Are you hungry? NO, I mean REALLY HUNGRY? If so, then this Pizza is for you. We start with our Classic Chicago Deep Dish Homemade Crust, then add LOADS of Mozzarella Cheese to fill it right to the brim along with any additional topping that you may want from our extensive list (all toppings are additional cost). Finally, we "put a lid on it" of more Chicago Dough, then top it with our Homemade Chunky AwesomeSauce, Fresh Basil, and Parmesan Cheese. It is more than a meal, it's a FEAST!

$38.00

Take & Bake New York Classic Pizza

This is Nicky's version of the New York Classic original with a soft, foldable crust. Nicky's adds our famous homemade Italian sauce by Marie, loads of Mozzarella Cheese along with your favorite toppings... Superb!

$18.50

Take & Bake Chicago Deep Dish Pizza

Enjoy the DEEP flaky crust with LOADS of Fresh Cheeses, 6 of them (Mozzarella, Fontina, Pecorino Romano, Parmesan, Asiago and a touch of Wisconsin Cheddar). So thick that you will probably need to use a fork!

$21.00

Take & Bake Detroit Pan Pizza

This unique Pizza is topped with a blend of Wisconsin Cheddar & Whole Milk Mozzarella Cheeses. What sets is apart however is the baked-on Wisconsin Cheddar crust around the edges of the pizza (cut in half to make 8-sides of baked-on goodness)!

$21.00

Take & Bake Philly Sicilian

The Pride of South Philly is true to it's Sicilian heritage with an airy crust, Nicky's special homemade sauce and a little "Philly" flair to set it apart from any other Sicilian Pizza that you may have had. Try it, we think that you will agree!

$18.50

Take & Bake Boston Veggie Pizza

This Pizza starts with our traditional soft crust topped with our special sauce and a blend of feta and mozzarella cheeses, then add: roasted sweet red peppers, kalamata olives, onions, spinach & tomato chunks. It is a combination that we think you will just love. Give it a try soon!

$22.50

Take & Bake Buffalo Chicken Pizza

If you want a Pizza that "Kicks it up a notch" with a uniquely bold flavor, try our NEW Buffalo Chicken Pizza. We start off with chunks of white meat chicken on our New York Style Crust, add Frank's Red Hot® Buffalo Chicken Sauce, some crumbled blue cheese, and a whole lot of Nicky's Love to make this a truly special pizza that we are sure you will enjoy.

$22.50

Take & Bake South Philly Cheesesteak Pizza

The cheesesteak deluxe is a truly great pizza keeping with the south philly cheesesteak tradition. We start with our philly sicilian crust then add: genuine thinly-sliced real sirloin steak, sautéed fried onions, and green bell peppers (additional toppings available to make it your own are extra). We then top it off with a blend of provolone and mozzarella cheeses to make it truly a deluxe pizza! It’s an explosion of south philly deliciousness in every bite that we think will rival any cheesesteak shop! Just try it, and see for yourself!

$24.00

Take & Bake White Pizza

A Pizza WITHOUT Red Pizza Sauce? Sounds crazy to some but believe it or not, White Pizza is the most popular style in Pennsylvania according to Slicelife. Try it, I think that you will like it as well. We start with our homemade, hand-stretched New York crust, then add a special Garlic sauce, lots of grated Whole Milk Mozzarella Cheese, Ricotta Cheese, then some Fresh Mozzarella for good measure. We then top it off with a special blend of herbs & spices. The result? Garlicky, Cheesy heaven!

$18.50

Take & Bake Meat Lovers

Mamma Ree suggested that we needed something for Meat Lovers. What we came up with is, in fact, a Meat Lovers Dream! We start off by giving you a choice of crusts, Chicago Deep Dish Crust or Philly Sicilian Crust. Sorry, there is so much on this pizza that a New York Crust won't hold it. We then add Nicky's Awesome Sauce, lots of freshly shredded Mozzarella Cheese, Pepperoni, Sweet Italian Sausage, Bacon, Ground Beef, Onions, and Green Bell Peppers. As the finishing touch we add our 5-cheese Italian blend, then our special herbs & spices. Of course, if there isn't enough on it already, you can certainly add more or customize it to your liking. It's also a great value ($7 savings vs. a-la-carte toppings). Give it a try sometime soon. NEW... Now available in Dairy-Free (NO CHEESE) for those who are lactose intolerant!

$25.00

Take & Bake Texas BBQ Pizza (Pork or Chicken)— NEW!

If you're Hankerin' for Somethin' a little Different, maybe with a little Texas BBQ Flair, this Pizza is for YOU! No red sauce on this one. Instead we replace it with Sweet Baby Rays® Original "Award Winning" BBQ Sauce. Then we top it off with your choice of our Savory Rotisserie Chicken or Slow-Roasted Pork, Raw Onion, then a blend of Mozzarella & Wisconsin Cheddar Cheeses. As a finishing touch we add a Swirl of even more BR Sauce! To make it your own, just add some extra toppings like bacon, peppers, tangy Gorgonzola (Blue Cheese) or perhaps something completely different!

$22.50

Take & Bake Hawaiian Pizza-NEW!

Enjoy the Savory Hawaiian Flavor of Smoked Premium Ham with the Sweetness of Dole® Pineapple with Pappa Nicky's Exclusive Homemade AwesomeSauce, Red Onions, and Bacon! For an added Kick, ask for a drizzle of BBQ Sauce on top (No Charge)! ~Try it Today~... We think that you will LOVE IT!

$22.50

New York Original Stromboli

This is the Original Stromboli with our Artisan Homemade New York Crust used as a Giant "Wrap" . Inside, the New York Original includes a base of Pappa Nicky's Homemade Marinara Sauce (or choose our chunky variety). We then load Lots of Fresh Mozzarella Cheese plus our 4-Cheese Italian Blend. On Top, we add some freshly grated Parmesan, and our special blend of herbs & spices. Finally we include two cups of Marinara for dipping! Feel free to add any of our large selection of toppings from meat to veggies.

$23.00

Italian Meats Stromboli - NOW INCLUDING PROSCIUTTO!

The Italian Meats Stromboli begins with our Own Marinara Sauce (or Nicky's Chunky Sauce), then add Mozzarella Cheese, Our 5-Cheese Italian Blend, Genoa Salami, Capicola, Sliced Pepperoni, and NOW PROSCIUTTO. Feel free to add your favorite veggies or additional meat to make it your own. On top we add original American Grana Parmesan cheese, and our special blend of herbs & spices then bake to perfection! We even include 2-cups of Marinara for dipping.

$25.00

Boston Veggie Stromboli

In addition to Nicky's Awesome Marinara and Mozzarella Cheese, the Boston Veggie Stromboli is a Veggie Lovers Delight stuffed with Onions, Green Bell Peppers, Roasted Red Peppers, Black Olives (or substitute Kalamata Olives), Sliced Mushrooms, and Diced Roma Tomatoes. On top we add Original PARMIGIANO REGGIANO CHEESE , and our special blend of herbs & spices. Finally, your Stromboli is baked to perfection. We even include 2-cups of Nicky's Awesome Marinara for dipping.

$24.00

Philly Cheesesteak Stromboli

Here's a Philly Favorite. This Stromboli starts with Nicky's Awesome Marinara Sauce, then lots of thinly sliced Original Philly® Sirloin Steak along with Sauteed Onions, Green Bell Peppers, then topped with a blend of Provolone and Mozzarella Cheeses, then MORE Nicky's Awesome Marinara Sauce. We then top it off with our special blend of herbs and spices, and bake it to perfection. Finally, we provide 2-cups of Nicky's Awesome Marinara for dipping.

$25.00

Mama Marie's Meatball Stromboli — NEW!

You are going to LOVE Mama Marie's Meatballs. She uses her family's heritage recipe to make them from scratch. Combine that with our Chunky AwesomeSauce, Mozzarella Cheese & our 5-Cheese Blend and you have a Winner for any meal. For an added level of flavor to set this Stromboli apart, we sprinkle a special blend of Seasoning on the crust. Mama Marie made a winner here!

$25.00

Ham & Cheese Stromboli-NEW!

By Popular Request, we have added a NEW Stromboli, Ham & Cheese. Made with our Homemade Crust, Special Chunky Sauce, Mozzarella and Provolone Cheeses then wrap it up with our freshly made dough. We think that you will LOVE IT!

$24.00

Pappa Nicky's Mozzarella Sticks

What better way to enjoy before, with or at the end your Pizza meal than our fresh and delicious lightly breaded Mozzarella Sticks with Pappa Nicky's AwesomeSauce! Available in 6-piece (w/1 sauce), 12-piece (w/2 sauces) or 18-piece (w/3 sauces).

$8.00

Mama Marie's Wings

Enjoy these Jumbo size Buffalo-style Chicken Wings along with your Pizza to compliment your meal. We make them with Genuine Franks Original Red Hot Sauce. They are available in 6-pc. (w/1 Sauce) ,12-pc. (w/2 Sauces, your choice), 18-pc. (w/3 Sauces, your choice) sizes. Dipping Sauces include your choice of Blue Cheese, Ranch sauce and/or Honey Mustard.

$8.00

Jersey Shore® French Fries - NEW!

"Simply the World's Best Fries"™, these Premium Quality French Fries will be a great addition to your Nicky's Deep Dish meal. LEGEND HAS IT: The first “French fries” (frites) originated in Belgium and were brought to the States by WWII veterans. Some of these same veterans heard rumors that the best “frites” were to be found at a roadside stand outside of Brussels. After risking their lives to find this stand, they indeed agreed these were Simply The World’s Best Fries™. Following a brief negotiation, the soldiers secured the recipe. The Jersey Shore Fry Company® now possesses this long-lost, legendary artisan recipe. We hope you enjoy some today.

$6.00

Boylan All Natural Soda-12 oz. Bottle

Perfect with Pizza, Boylan® Pure Cane Sugar Sodas are a refreshing addition to our menu. Try some today. Available individually and in a 4-pack carrier ($2.50 OFF from individual bottle purchase) or an 8-pack ($5.00 OFF from individual bottle purchase) Mix & Match Flavors!

$2.50

4 Pack Boylan® Natural Craft Soda (1.42L)

SAVE $2.50 on a 4-Pack. Perfect with Pizza, Boylan® Natural Craft Sodas are a refreshing addition to our menu. Try some today. Available individually and in a 4-pack carrier. Mix & Match Flavors, or all the same!

$7.50

8-Pack Boylan Natural Craft Sodas (2.8L)

SAVE $5.00 an 8-Pack of Boylan® Natural Craft Soda! Mix & Match all of the great flavors from old-fashioned Root Beer to Orange to Creamy Birch Beer to Original Cola, and more!

$15.00

Crystal Geyser Natural Alpine Spring Water

Pure Spring Water in 16.9 oz. recyclable bottles.

$1.50

Wing Ding Deal

This Deal is too good to pass up! You get 1- Philly Sicilian or New York Classic Pizza (Chicago or Detroit Pizza also available for an extra $3) NOW with one topping at NO ADDITIONAL CHARGE (sausage, pepperoni or veggie); 1-12 pc. Marie's Hot Wings, and a 4-Pack of Boylan® Natural Craft Soda (mix & match flavors). All this at a Special Price. THAT'S A $15 SAVINGS from our regular menu price!

$44.00

SUPER WING DING DEAL!

Even MORE of a Good Thing at a SUPER PRICE! The Deal Includes: 2-Philly Sicilian and/or New York Classic Pizzas (Chicago, Detroit Pizzas also available for an extra $4) w/one additional topping at no extra charge. Other toppings may be added at extra cost. 2-12 Pc. Buffalo Chicken Wings w/4 sauces of your choice (Ranch, Blue Cheese and Honey BBQ) 2-12 Pc. Mozzarella Sticks w/4 cups of Nicky's Marinara Sauce. 2-4 Packs of Boylan® Natural Craft Sodas (mix & match flavors). ALL THIS FOR A SUPER PRICE OF $88.00 OR $92.00 for a Chicago/Detroit Combo! That's a $30 SAVINGS FROM OUR REGULAR MENU PRICE!

$88.00

Boston Style Veggie Pizza

This pizza starts with your choice of our freshly made from scratch crusts (classic traditional, Chicago or Sicilian) topped with Pappa Nicky's chunky AwesomeSauce. We then add: roasted sweet red peppers, kalamata olives, onions, spinach & diced tomato. It is a combination that we think you will just love. Give it a try soon! For diets that either cannot tolerate or choose not to consume dairy cheese, we offer Violife™ vegetable-based cheese (vegan approved). For those on a flexitarian diet that may include meats for added protein, you can add any of our wide variety of beef, pork, or chicken toppings.

$26.00

Meat-Veggie Flexitarian Pizza

NEW! A very unique pizza inspired by a great customer who adheres to a flexitarian diet (a diet consisting of a a lot of vegetables, with some basic meats such as beef, chicken or pork but less than a standard American diet). Our version includes your choice of meats, and vegetables with either a no-cheese or Violife™ Vegan approved cheese along with Pappa Nicky's Chunky Sauce. We put it all on our Chicago Deep Dish Crust to hold it all. Look at this as your own custom pizza based on your special diet.

$32.00

Vegan Veggie Stromboli

This Stromboli starts with our freshly made from scratch classic traditional crust wrap. It's then filled with Pappa Nicky's chunky AwesomeSauce. We then add: roasted sweet red peppers, kalamata olives, onions, spinach & diced tomato. It is a combination that we think you will just love. You may select your Stromboli with NO CHEESE or with Violife™ (Vegan Approved) mozzarella cheese. For those who follow a flexitarian diet that permits some meat products, feel free to add any of our beef, chicken or pork meats inside. Any way that you like it, we will try to do it!

$25.00